Four steps toward vitality in our denomination

By Adam Hamilton ••• Special Contributor

Adam Hamilton

The Rev. Adam Hamilton, mega-church pastor and popular author, shares his pre-General Conference thoughts on revitalizing the denomination.

As an aside, I don’t believe that restructuring the general boards is the key to having a future with hope; I see it as an opportunity to more effectively do the work of the church. This is more than rearranging the proverbial “deck chairs on the Titanic” but if this is all that we do, the Titanic will still sink.

Ensure that our seminaries are preparing graduates to create vital congregations.

I chair the board at Saint Paul School of Theology in Kansas City, one of our 13 United Methodist seminaries. I am proud of the work our faculty do and believe in them. Our mission as a seminary is to “educate leaders to make disciples for Jesus Christ, to renew the church and to transform the world.” What is lacking, not only for Saint Paul, but for most of our seminaries, is a clear mandate from the United Methodist Church that identifies the specific skills we must provide so that our graduates are prepared to revitalize declining congregations, to effectively launch new congregations, and to reach new generations of young people while continuing to serve the older members of our congregations.

Raise up 2,000 gifted, outstanding young adult clergy to reach new generations.

We currently have more clergy than we need in the United Methodist Church. Our shrinking numbers have left us with something like 800 more clergy than we need. But our clergy are nearly 60 years old on average. We have thousands who will be retiring in the next 10 years. The single most important key to revitalizing most churches is the shepherd who is appointed to love and lead the flock. Gifted and committed lay people eventually give up in frustration when their clergy are ineffective. When a gifted and effective clergy is sent to a local congregation that is struggling, the results are often surprising.

I recently spoke with 12 clergy across the United States who had been assigned to declining congregations that are now growing. Most were part-time appointments. When they arrived at their churches, average worship attendance ranged from 8 to 120. These were our typical churches. Only a couple of them were in growing communities, yet all of them had doubled, tripled or quadrupled in size in the last five years. They shared an emphasis on caring for people, preaching effective sermons, intentional outreach to the community and passionate, visionary leaders.

We need outstanding second career clergy, and I am grateful for them, but if we are going to reach new generations of young people, we must focus a great deal of our attention on raising up a new generation of clergy. All of these 12 pastors were under age 40 when they were assigned to their churches. We’ve seen a dramatic decline in the number of children in our churches. We’ve got to raise up a generation of clergy who will reach today’s 5-year-olds.

The IOT continues to propose setting aside a fund from General Church apportionments to provide scholarships for gifted young adults to pursue ordained ministry. Many of these young adults are in junior high or high school right now. By the time they graduate from seminary, thousands of our existing clergy will have retired. This initiative alone could determine whether our church has a future.

At the church that I serve we invite children to begin considering whether God might be calling them to be pastors when they receive their third-grade Bibles. We focus on this in one session of confirmation, and I preach about listening for God’s call at least once a year. Our members have set aside money in the budget and from memorial gifts to fund scholarships to raise up a new generation of gifted pastors.

Encourage strategic partnerships between small and large churches.

Finally, in a denomination where 19,000 of our churches have less than 60 people per weekend in worship attendance, I believe we must find ways to create voluntary partnerships in which churches work together to strengthen one another. The Call to Action study found that we have 5,000 highly vital congregations in the U.S. What would it look like for each highly vital church to invite one or two less vital congregations to partner with them in the hope of creating two or three highly vital churches?

In Indiana, a church of 220 per weekend in worship has voluntarily partnered with two churches with an average attendance of 14 each, supplying the pulpit with lay and clergy and sharing resources. All three churches are stronger today. At Resurrection, we are piloting a program in which we’re partnering with three smaller churches across the U.S., offering coaching, tools and Resurrection’s sermons via video to see if these resources can help revitalize these churches.

If you are one of those highly vital congregations, would you be willing to partner with smaller churches that are struggling, to help them have a future with hope? If you are a smaller church, would you be interested in partnering and sharing resources with churches that are growing? This connectionalism would see our large number of smaller churches not as a liability but a tremendous opportunity.

We stand at an important crossroads as we go into General Conference. If fear of change immobilizes us, we have a very limited future. But I believe that bringing our general boards together to work as one team to serve the church, giving a clear mandate to our seminaries on the practical skills our pastors must be trained in to revitalize existing churches, raising up 2,000 outstanding young clergy in the next 12 years, and creating voluntary partnerships between churches could lead us down a different path, one that offers us a future with hope.

The Rev. Hamilton is pastor of the United Methodist Church of the Resurrection in Leawood, Kan. This article first appeared in Circuit Rider (Feb/Mar/Apr 2012) and online at Follow General Conference coverage from Circuit Rider and Ministry Matters at

Leave a Reply

The United Methodist Reporter wants to encourage lively conversation about The United Methodist Church and our articles in the belief that Christian conversation (what Wesley would call conferencing) is a means of grace. While we support passionate debate, we cannot allow language that demeans or demonizes others, and we reserve the right to delete any comment we believe to be harmful or inappropriate. We encourage all to remember that we are all broken and in need of Christ's grace, and that we all see through the glass darkly until that time we when reach full perfection in love. May your speech here be tempered with love, and reflection of the fruits of love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. After all, "There is no law against things like this." (Galatians 5:22-23)
Notify of
%d bloggers like this: