Dealing with ‘wounded’ United Methodist Church

By Bishop Minerva Carcaño, Special Contributor…

Bishop Minerva Carcaño

Many good things happened at General Conference. They did not necessarily happen through legislative processes though some of the good came through our legislative work.

Establishing a global theological education fund to help prepare persons for ministry, our commitment to mission and ministry around the world supported by a strong financial plan, the commissioning of missionaries to serve in a great variety of settings, our continued commitment to U.S. racial ethnic plans, our ecumenical work, and certainly our Service of Repentance and our clear covenant to repair the cruel offenses we have committed against indigenous peoples—these were all good things that came from General Conference.

I also rejoice in the great diversity we saw at this GC. I heard many more voices from young people and persons from Africa, the Philippines and Europe. There were, in my opinion, deeper conversations on the floor this time about what it means to be the church.

But here is where I saw our woundedness. We showed it through our fear of failure, our racism and sexism, our homophobia and our U.S.-centric attitude.

I support our direction for renewed ministry among our congregations in the U.S. Our Vital Congregations efforts to help our churches become more fruitful in making disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world are critical; but our efforts should never compromise our integrity out of a fear of failure. What I saw in the effort to pass the Call to Action and IOT recommendations felt to me like a manipulation of the process and rules of decision-making that govern our General Conference.

We are in decline in our U.S. ministry, a decline that concerns all of us, but if we allow a fear of failure to so dominate our thinking and our work that we are willing to lose our integrity in order to pass a piece of church legislation, then we have lost already: lost our way, our purpose and mission, our faithfulness. I believe we must have serious conversations about what happened at this General Conference, starting with conversation at the table of our Council of Bishops.

Salt in wound

Our renewed racism and sexism was captured in the words of a delegate who in an effort to eliminate our Commissions on Religion & Race and Status & Role of Women rose and stated that she was a pastor and received the flyers of training events of these commissions and the events weren’t helpful to her one bit. Her language was derogatory of the work of these commissions who have long labored to help us overcome our racism and sexism, obstacles to our fully being the body of Christ Jesus.

Our homophobia was blatant as we heard delegates compare homosexuality to bestiality, and voice other dehumanizing expressions against our LGBT brothers and sisters. Delegates from Africa once again proclaimed that their anti-homosexual stand was what U.S. missionaries taught them. I sat there wondering when our African delegates will grow up.

It has been 200 years since U.S. Methodist missionaries began work in Africa: long enough for African Methodists to do their own thinking about this concern and others. Our conservative U.S. United Methodists continue to depend on the conservative vote of African and Filipino delegates to maintain our exclusionary position on homosexuality, a position I believe would be changed if a U.S. vote were taken. The manner in which we deal with homosexuality affects our ministry in the U.S., and we are poorer for it. It is time for us to let go of our wrong position and be the church of Christ Jesus, a church that excludes no one.

Then there is the U.S. centrism that has forever led our General Conferences, from our insistence on the use of Robert’s Rules of Order, a system of decision-making used in the U.S. but nowhere else in our global church’s decision making processes, to lengthy discussions of U.S. issues with no comparable discussion of issues relevant to ministry in other places. I was terribly embarrassed when much time was again given to discussion about our U.S. clergy benefits. It is not that our clergy do not deserve to be supported through equitable compensation, health and pension benefits. It is that we in the U.S. have benefits that others in our connectional church do not have.

Why should our sisters and brothers from the Philippines, Africa and Europe be subjected to our long discussions about such matters? It felt to me like salt in the wound of a church that is inequitable and reflects the economic values of the world rather than the economic values of the kingdom of God.

Watching world

I have heard over and over the statement that without the U.S. church the rest of United Methodism will fail because the U.S. church foots the bill. I no longer believe this U.S.-centric statement. We have much to learn from United Methodists in other regions of the world who give sacrificially, for whom serving Christ Jesus is primary, and who believe that, above all, we are citizens of the reign of God who has come among us with grace and mercy through Christ Jesus, and who does stand as the Sovereign One above all powers and principalities.

One day during plenary, during a particularly difficult discussion, a delegate expressed concern about the witness the body was giving. The delegate said, “The world is watching us.” A few minutes later another delegate rose and said, “If we think the world is watching us, we are delusional!” Well, the next day The New York Times reported on our General Conference discussion! The world is watching!

Let’s deal with our woundedness, so we can focus on the woundedness of the world. Let’s pray to the Lord for our healing so that we can be His church in the world, agents of His grace and mercy.


Bishop Carcaño leads the Desert Southwest Conference.  This essay appeared first on the conference’s “Desert Connections” website.

Leave a Reply

The United Methodist Reporter wants to encourage lively conversation about The United Methodist Church and our articles in the belief that Christian conversation (what Wesley would call conferencing) is a means of grace. While we support passionate debate, we cannot allow language that demeans or demonizes others, and we reserve the right to delete any comment we believe to be harmful or inappropriate. We encourage all to remember that we are all broken and in need of Christ's grace, and that we all see through the glass darkly until that time we when reach full perfection in love. May your speech here be tempered with love, and reflection of the fruits of love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. After all, "There is no law against things like this." (Galatians 5:22-23)
5 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
Clark Gordonmjsizemdknudsonmichigan pastorellinger Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Clark Gordon

Thank God for the righteous people of Africa voting down the abomination know as homosexuality, please continue pray for the United States, many parts of the church continue to defy God and are committing blasephemy against God by illegally marrying same sex individuals


I am very troubled about the Methodist leadership division in many areas. How can Bishop Carcano say that the General Conference was wrong in its decisions – especially prohibiting homosexual pastors and leaders? Since the Bible states practicing homosexuality is a sexual sin, how could any Christian/Methodist leader vote otherwise. Since the General Conference voted and upheld the UMC view of homsexuality, isn't the leadership supposed to support "its" decison. One voice. That's what leaders do. They support their organization's decisions. But to be fair, put the homosexual issue before the Wesley quadrilateral! Test it. Test any issue that comes… Read more »


Bishop Carano phrases my concerns more eloquently and succinctly than I could do. I admire her directness in expressing her regrets. It is good we have such voices speaking about the need to seek changes.
Thanks and blessings to her.

michigan pastor
michigan pastor

Please, please make Bishop Carcano the voice of UMC.

May her tribe increase.


I appreciate reading Bishop Carcano's statement. I whole-hearatedly concur wtih her thinking on all of this..
Now, Bishop, I implore you to begin this conversation aroudnd that table of the Council of Bishops. What was it again that Mordeci said to Esther….? Thank you for your strong voice.

John Wesly said something like this: I do not fear Methodism will be lost in America. I fear it will lose it's spirit and exist only as an empty sect.

Janet Ellinger, Wsiconsin

%d bloggers like this: