United Methodist ‘church’ on a ferry boat

By Kathleen Barry, United Methodist News Service…

How do you attract tourists to worship with your church during the months of summer vacation?

The little Michigan towns of St. Ignace and Mackinaw City have both tourists and locals standing in line for 30 minutes for a seat at their Vesper Cruise services led by various local denominations.

On a balmy August evening onboard the Arnold Ferry boat called “Ottawa” stands a man in sandals, shorts and grey sweatshirt who could pass for a “fudgie”—the nickname given to tourists who travel to the Upper Peninsula of Michigan to vacation and buy fudge.

Allison Colegrove of St. Ignace United Methodist Church in St. Ignace, Mich., celebrates her 10th birthday riding the evening Vesper Cruise. Allison was one of four youths sent by the church to attend camp this summer at Camp Michigamme. UMNS PHOTOS BY KATHLEEN BARRY

However, as the ferry pulls away from Dock #1 in St. Ignace, his real mission is revealed. Accompanied by a musician and church members from St. Ignace United Methodist Church, the Rev. Erik Alsgaard picks up a microphone and energetically welcomes the 221 passengers aboard to the Friday August evening vespers. Painted words on the wall behind Mr. Alsgaard conveys a message saying that there are 255 adult life jackets onboard, enough for everyone.

Under the Mighty Mac

“This is the only church you go where they tell the pastor to be louder,” jokes Mr. Alsgaard as he competes with the sounds of engine and boat whistle.

Passengers sit on green wooden benches while the ferry chugs into the Great Lake Huron water to begin its journey beneath the Mackinac Bridge—“Mighty Mac,” as it is known locally, the nickname given to the five-mile suspension bridge connecting the lower and upper portions of Michigan. The crowd is an eclectic mixture of tourists, St. Ignace residents and youth group members.

The six-week vespers program begins each summer on the 4th of July, and a different local church leads the service every Friday evening. Tonight is sponsored by the United Methodists.

Mr. Alsgaard says that he always does a version of the creation story from Genesis. As the sky darkens into dusk and the boat travels below the 552-foot-tall bridge, it’s hard not to be in awe of God’s creation.

While song sheets are passed out, Mr. Alsgaard engages the crowd. Soon we learn that passengers include young people from the United Methodist Church for All People in Columbus, Ohio, who are doing mission work at White Pine Community UMC in White Pine, Mich. There are also Lutheran and Southern Baptist youth groups aboard who are attending church camps in the area. Some church members attend for the first time. Tourists are just happy for a boat ride.

Connecting people

During the singing, Ruth Paquin hands out souvenir postcards of the bridge. Ms. Paquin’s grandfather was the Methodist pastor in St. Ignace from 1951 to 1963. The bridge opened in 1957. The summer population swells with vacationers, while those who brave the intense winters to live as permanent residents are much fewer in number.

“It’s God’s Country; sometimes God only knows why we live here,” Ms. Paquin jokes.

The Rev. Erik Alsgaard leads worship by reading the Creation story to 221 passengers on the free, weekly cruise that travels in the Straits of Mackinac and beneath the Mackinac Bridge. “It’s another ‘door’ to have people welcomed by the community,” he says.

She is also a member of St. Ignace UMC, as is Allison Colegrove, who is on her first Vesper Cruise to celebrate her 10th birthday. Allison was baptized in March by Mr. Alsgaard and is one of four youth that St. Ignace sponsored at Camp Michigamme this summer. She is embarrassed when passengers sing “Happy Birthday,” but says that the cruise is “very cool.” Her grandmother, Carolyn Tamlyn, shared that Allison told her, “If I didn’t go to church, I would just think that Easter and Christmas were another fun day.”

The Vesper Cruise combines singing of hymns, meditation, a free boat ride and a freewill offering. There is almost always money left over to help local ministry. One that Mr. Alsgaard is especially proud of is the thrift store created by Project HOPE, made up of six local churches, which makes as much as $1,500 per day and has contributed more than $500,000 in mission assistance since its creation six years ago. Tom North, a church member for 42 years, mentions that church attendance at St. Ignace UMC is up 30 percent. Like the “Mighty Mac,” the little church of 200 members is busy connecting people, reaching out and making a difference.

“The Vesper Cruise is all about hospitality,” noted Mr. Alsgaard. “It’s another ‘door’ to have people welcomed by the community.” He added that he’s “not trying to convert” during the boat ride but that it’s “just a chance to relax, enjoy the scenery, worship, enjoy what God has given us and reflect on Scripture. We want to make sure they (the passengers) have a place to be welcomed in Christ’s name.”

As the boat ride ends back at the dock, a giant rainbow appears in the sky as if on cue, a perfect ending to an evening that began with the story of creation. When Mr. Alsgaard saw the rainbow he “got chills.”

“The rainbow . . . it was a Holy Spirit moment for me—a God moment.”

Special Contributor to UMR

Special Contributor

This story was written by a special contributor to The United Methodist Reporter. You may send your article submissions to

Leave a Reply

The United Methodist Reporter wants to encourage lively conversation about The United Methodist Church and our articles in the belief that Christian conversation (what Wesley would call conferencing) is a means of grace. While we support passionate debate, we cannot allow language that demeans or demonizes others, and we reserve the right to delete any comment we believe to be harmful or inappropriate. We encourage all to remember that we are all broken and in need of Christ's grace, and that we all see through the glass darkly until that time we when reach full perfection in love. May your speech here be tempered with love, and reflection of the fruits of love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. After all, "There is no law against things like this." (Galatians 5:22-23)
Notify of
%d bloggers like this: