To rise from the ashes – Churches face challenge of recovering from fires

It’s every congregation’s worst nightmare. Fire strikes and the church building that members have loved for decades is suddenly gone or seriously damaged. Three churches in the UMC’s Arkansas Conference and congregations in six other states understand that nightmare all too well as they recover from recent fires.

The Rev. Debbye Harrison (center), pastor of Hickory Plains UMC, examines what remains of the church sanctuary along with her son Bryce (l), grandson Christian and a close friend, Ann Brumbelow. ARKANSAS UNITED METHODIST PHOTO BY AMY FORBUS

One fire, ignited by lightning, destroyed the Hickory Plains United Methodist Church near Carlisle, Ark., on May 30, 2012.

“Our building was a total loss, even though it took nearly three months before the insurance company made its final decision,” said the Rev. Deborah D. Harrison. “A quick-moving thunderstorm went through about noon that day, but the fire wasn’t discovered until 3:15 p.m.”

The congregation is meeting in a former Baptist church. “We are now in the slow process of getting our plans ready and approved by the district committee on location and buildings,” Ms. Harrison said. “The insurance company [State Auto] is paying $485,000 for the building.

“We had a major fundraiser just a few weeks after the fire. The money from that, plus donations gave us an extra $14,000. If we run out of money, our plans are to have more fundraisers.”

Ms. Harrison is grateful for prayers and reminders that people care. “The outpouring of love and support,” she said, “has been inspiring. I have especially appreciated all of the people, near and far—many total strangers—who have sent condolences and reminded us that they are praying for us.

“I am in the middle of this experience, but I believe it needs more prayer than money. My very small congregation [47 members] has been forced to work together more closely than ever before, and we are recovering from some fractious meetings and differences of ideas. . . . A church is a much more personal belonging than you can imagine. People take it very personally, and trying to step back for a broader view is a challenge to their personal loss.”

A fire in December destroyed the sanctuary, office area and part of the fellowship hall of Gideon Grove UMC in Stokesdale, N.C. Five United Methodist churches in the Stokesdale area experienced recent fires, all arson-related. UMNS PHOTO COURTESY THE REV. NANCY RANKIN

In September 2011, an arsonist torched Living Waters at Centerton (Ark.) United Methodist Church, and the building was a total loss.

“The fire was caused by someone pouring gasoline all over the altar and igniting it,” said the Rev. Blake A. Lasater. “After the first fire was extinguished that night, the arsonist came back with more gasoline and reignited the fire, causing it to travel underneath the flooring and out the back of the church where it wasn’t spotted until the next morning. The insurance investigator has turned his findings over to the state fire marshal for further investigation.”

A year and a half later, no one has been arrested.

Community response to the fire was immediate. A Baptist church offered pastoral support and sent its praise band the Sunday after the fire to lead the service. “They also donated sound and music equipment to be used while we are nomadic,” Mr. Lasater added. A recently closed United Methodist church in Oklahoma donated church furnishings.

‘God is still present’

Now meeting in an elementary school, the congregation is looking forward to completion of a new building, under

Tips on church property insurance

By Paul Stephens, United Methodist News Service

In the past 10 months, fire destroyed or damaged more than a dozen UM church properties across the United States.

The insured property value ranged from $10,000 to $3.3 million, but several churches lacked adequate insurance to cover full replacement costs. Here are things churches can do to protect themselves.

Market value vs. replacement value

Understand the difference between market value and replacement value when buying or evaluating your insurance policy.

The market value is the price at which the church building could sell on the open market today. The replacement value is how much it would cost to rebuild the structure to its current state.

It is not unusual for a church to be worth, say $600,000 at market value, but to have a replacement value of $1.5 million.

Church leaders must understand that in the event of a total loss, it is imperative to have the buildings insured to full replacement value if they would want them completely rebuilt.

The congregation obviously will pay more to insure the property adequately but nothing like what it would pay if it found itself underinsured.

What to consider when purchasing insurance

First, church leaders should only purchase coverage from companies that specialize in church risks. Some of these companies are United Methodist Insurance, Cincinnati Insurance, Church Mutual, Brotherhood Mutual and GuideOne.

By doing this, the church deals with carriers that understand the intricacies of church claims and coverage issues.

Second, after narrowing your field to church carriers, the congregation should determine minimum insurance requirements in terms of what constitutes acceptable coverage limits.

Even in the church-insurance market, you will find wide variations in the types and levels of coverage provided. In terms of church property, the congregation should require each company to complete a “replacement-cost appraisal” and match the results to reality in that ZIP code.

Risk management

When it comes to property losses such as fire, a combination of “adequate risk-management” techniques can go a long way.

There are small things that I refer to as “low-hanging fruit” that churches can address for little or no expense. These include proper housekeeping, proper storage of flammables, proper use of electricity in terms of avoiding extension cords, installation of smoke detectors, clear exits and proper lighting. Additionally, lightning rods, sprinkler systems and monitored central-station fire alarms, while more expensive, can substantially limit the severity of a fire.

For more information visit, or call (800) 975-5442.

Mr. Stephens is vice president of marketing and risk-management services for the Church Insurance Agency Corporation, a service provider to United Methodist Insurance. UMI is a wholly owned, nonprofit subsidiary of the UMC’s General Council on Finance and Administration.

construction on the old site. “The fire . . . burned a hole in the middle of the first floor, which is built into the brick walls,” Mr. Lasater said. There was “no way to replace the floor and to ensure the two-story brick structure would not collapse on itself.

“Insurance [State Farm] only covered half the expenses, deeming that the old building was salvageable,” he added. “However, our tests and studies showed that it wasn’t.

“There really is no way to assess the dollar value of the building,” Mr. Lasater said. “It would take $1.5 million to put it back with all the code updates. It was insured for $900,000, but insurance only paid $500,000. They would only pay the full amount if we actually started remodeling the old church, which we deemed to be a total loss. Architectural and engineering fees, plus city permitting to remodel, would have been substantial, and then we would have discovered the building could not be salvaged. In other words, they wanted us to tear out the floor and if the building caved in, they would have paid the full amount. By then we would have already spent the $400,000 to get to that point, so we decided to cut our losses and start all over with the half-payout.”

He reminded other congregations, “Insurance only replaces. It does not rebuild. Make sure you have adequate funds to actually rebuild the church, not just its value. Those two items may seem to be the same, but they are totally different.”

God is still present, even in difficult times, Mr. Lasater said. “You’ve still got a mission and a ministry.”

A late-night lightning strike on Oct. 22, 2012, sparked a fire at Wiggins Memorial UMC, Fayetteville, Ark. The flames were contained in Heritage Hall, but extensive smoke damage throughout the facility left the congregation temporarily displaced. “We are still waiting to receive the final amounts for building and contents,” said the Rev. Nan Nelson, senior pastor. The facility is insured by GuideOne for $10,000.

Area churches continue to support the congregation. Members are worshipping with Trinity UMC in Fayetteville until building rehabilitation is completed. Other congregations are hosting the Cub Scout troop and assisting with cleanup.

Ms. Nelson praised the power of social media, which enabled friends and colleagues to reach out immediately to her and the congregation.

Despite the passage of time, she said, a strong smoke odor has returned to the premises, thus changing the inventory of damaged property. “We have added carpet and pew pads in the sanctuary to our list of damaged content,” Ms. Nelson said. “Ozone machines were placed in the church . . . to remove the smoke odor.”

‘Faithful and strong’

Congregations in Georgia, Indiana, Nebraska, South Carolina, Virginia and Illinois also experienced recent fires.

The Rev. Reggie Williams, pastor of South Columbus United Methodist Church in Georgia, expressed optimism after fire, suspected to be electrical, damaged his church on Nov. 23. “We’re holding on to Scripture. . . . Even in the midst of this, God’s hand is upon us, and we will come back stronger.”

On Dec. 3, a fire—sparked by an Advent candle—tore through the sanctuary of the recently renovated Friend United Methodist Church in Friend, Neb. “The interior of the sanctuary is a total loss,” said the Rev. Paixao Baptista, “but the structure is still viable.” The congregation is meeting in a funeral home chapel while the sanctuary undergoes repairs. The dollar value of the property insurance from Church Mutual is $1.8 million, including $1.5 million for the building and $300,000 for contents.

“The community support has been wonderful,” Mr. Baptista said, including prayer and financial assistance for uncovered expenses and a necessary upgrade. “It’s a hard situation, but people are faithful and strong.”

A Dec. 31 fire destroyed the sanctuary of Taylor Chapel UMC in Fort Wayne, Ind. The Rev. Steven K. Conner, senior pastor, agreed with the comment of a lay leader: “We’re still together as a people. We still have our mission; we still have work to do.”

Also picking up the pieces after a lightning strike on Jan. 2 ignited a fire is Shiloh UMC, Lynchburg, S.C. The inferno destroyed the 182-year-old structure.

Three weeks later, on Jan. 23, fire engulfed the 135-year-old Adams United Methodist Church in Parksley, Va. The sanctuary appeared a total loss, but firefighters tried to save the adjacent fellowship hall. According to a local news source, early reports suggested the fire was not the result of arson.

In Robinson, Ill., members of First UMC are dealing with a similar tragedy that struck their congregation on Christmas Day.

A fire of “undetermined” origin consumed the 1899 building, which included the sanctuary and a partial basement. However, the half-century-old education building, which butted up to the sanctuary, received only water and smoke damage. All of the contents were lost.

“We are meeting at Otterbein United Methodist Church here in Robinson,” the Rev. Tiffany Black said. “The community has been wonderful. There have been many prayers and acts of love. We have been richly blessed.” After the education building is repaired, the congregation will return there to worship in the fellowship hall.

The facilities, valued at $3.3 million, were insured for $3.5 million by Cincinnati Financial Corp. “They are estimating it to cost $2.5 million to rebuild the structure of the sanctuary,” the pastor said, “and then we would need to add pews, organ, pulpit, sound system and so forth.

“We are still early on in the whole process, and I am sure I will learn so much more before all is said and done. As far as rebuilding, we do not know what the future holds at this time.” A newly formed study committee will determine the congregation’s next steps.

Ms. Black refuses to let the situation overwhelm her or her parishioners.

“There is no need to panic,” she said. “Everything will get done in due time. The most important thing is to take care of one another and stand strong as a church. Treat it as a funeral and give the people time to share and grieve. While there are memories, it was a building and the people are the church.”


Leave a Reply

The United Methodist Reporter wants to encourage lively conversation about The United Methodist Church and our articles in the belief that Christian conversation (what Wesley would call conferencing) is a means of grace. While we support passionate debate, we cannot allow language that demeans or demonizes others, and we reserve the right to delete any comment we believe to be harmful or inappropriate. We encourage all to remember that we are all broken and in need of Christ's grace, and that we all see through the glass darkly until that time we when reach full perfection in love. May your speech here be tempered with love, and reflection of the fruits of love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. After all, "There is no law against things like this." (Galatians 5:22-23)
Notify of
%d bloggers like this: