Wesleyan Wisdom: Will We Pay the Price of a Reality Check?

The Old South, appropriately, has been both mocked and ridiculed for euphemistically “sipping mint juleps under the magnolia tree” using vintage family china and carrying on a conversation reflective of the Antebellum days. Thousands lived out their days in denial of the new world around them, and sadly, they contributed almost nothing to that world as they either wrung their hands or reminisced about dead heroes.   I have a very wise friend  “Northern”  friend with whom I engage in “holy conversation” who often uses the term, “reality check.”   She will not allow me the luxury of living in the past.  She forces me to engage the world that “is,” not the world that is “gone with the wind.”  Dr. Nido Qubein, who has led High Point University from the academic world of mediocrity to the summit of excellence, reminds us trustees and the returning alumni, “You can visit the past, but you cannot live there anymore.”

Perhaps my imagination is absurd, but I think not, for I see, hear, and read of so many brilliant leaders of our present  message, mission, and method who are living with old paradigms  Their response (which is typical) to the changes in our culture is to try harder and to circle the wagons, going into defense mode, even to the point of developing an “Alamo complex.”   Let us remember that all the men in the Alamo became dead heroes—heroes, yes, but dead! We United Methodists are not called to a “last stand” of our traditions until the surrounding culture overwhelms us.  We are called to be Jesus people in this time and in our present place.

Will Rogers was right: “Things ain’t like they used to be and never wuz.”

When do you think was the “golden age” of Methodism or the EUB Church?   If you look at any pictures of almost any congregation in the days following World War II you generally will see many more people than are attending that same church today.  If attendance were the mission, those were the golden years.

However, the only voice of social justice was an annual commitment card to abstain from the use of alcoholic beverages for the ensuing year and to echo the United Nation mantras about world peace and “one world order” or the cold war invective against “godless communism.”   Very little was said about racism until “Brown vs. the Board of Education” came before the Supreme Court in 1954.  The word “feminism” was barely in the dictionary — not in common use, and certainly not in the pulpit. Sunday School literature taught children a surreal view of what it meant to follow Jesus—“just be a good boy or good girl.” The cross and the atonement were excised from all children’s literature.  Jesus was portrayed as “gentle Jesus, meek and mild.” Billboards across the land promised that “the family that prays together stays together.” We never articulated the possibility of child molestation or marital abuse. Most sermons were topical, not biblical. Even Easter sermons talked about “immorality,” not the resurrection of Christ.

Until 1964, church growth was biological.  It stopped almost precisely simultaneously with the advent of the birth control pill.   One dimension of this over-looked reality was the decline of the rural church.  The “Town and Country Movement” launched in the 1940’s developed enough message and muscle to  have every seminary place a  professor of “T own and Country Work” on its faculty, but all of t hem were rural sociologists, not  mentors on bringing people to Jesus Christ!   With incredible denominational loyalty, the rural areas were a pipeline to the burgeoning  suburbs.  By the late 1950’s, we were experiencing what Gibson Winters of Garrett Evangelical Biblical Institute called the “suburban captivity of the church.”  Young preachers used their rural parishes as stepping stones to  growing suburbs and “First Church: Jerusalem.”   The same was true of strong churches whose constituency was “blue collar,” often the center of a mill or mine village.   Indeed there was a time that the majority of pastors came from our rural and blue collar churches.  The pastor was the hero of children and youth and God used the opportunity to call them to preach.

We sold our soul to the culture.  The prophecy Richard Niebuhr made in the 1930’s came true by the 1950’s—culture had so effectively contextualized Christ that  many of our Sunday School and pulpit  message sounded like what  Diana Butler Bass calls “the Rotary Club at prayer.”   Thousands of rural churches and mill & miner village churches were closed, creating a vacuum of ministry that was filled by fundamentalist churches whose  positive message was, “Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved” and whose negative message was, “you are a passenger on a hellbound train.”  Their message touched the same primordial need that “country music” touched—the pathos of sin.  Unlike the “somebody done somebody wrong” songs, the gospel of the footstomping, arm-waving evangelist was, “Wilt thou be saved? Then why not tonight?”  It struck a responsive chord.  In the communities and villages we abandoned, they built a new religious ethos.

Just like the proverbial “frog in the kettle,” our vital breathe was slowly dying.  We were aided and abetted in our denial by two secular factors:

  • As medical science gave us a steady increase of life expectancy pharmaceutical houses  developed a steady stream of “wonder drugs,” we found ourselves sitting in the pew and tithing to the budget at an ages when our parents and grandparents had been either in rocking chairs or their graves.   The dependable nucleus of congregations in every demographic situation became increasingly older.  Fewer children were being born and fewer young adults were remaining in either the EUB or Methodist Churches.
  • The free enterprise democratic capitalism created enormous new wealth.  People of ordinary circumstances began a lifestyle of affluence that only the wealthy had known in previous generations.    Appreciated stocks and rising real estate values enabled painless philanthropy. An annual “stewardship campaign” became the norm, with people pledging to support the church during the ensuing year.  Slowly lay ministry lessened and paid staff ministry increased.  Capital campaigns made possible the erection of aesthetically impressive sanctuaries.  As Sunday School began to ebb, churches were sold the “field of dreams” philosophy that a “Family Life Center” would be the panacea that would bring back the young people. However, rather then bring families to the church, these gymnasiums (for that is what they really were) required more custodial staff, higher insurance rates and larger utility bills, and only rarely brought more people into the church.

As the 1960’s saw violent socio-economic unrest  and change, the Methodists and Evangelical United Brethren were locked into an obsession with the evils of denominationalism.  The highest  priority  between 1904-1939  was “unification”–the merger of three  branches of Methodism.  By the late 1950’s the highest  priority was the dual track of abolishing the racist Central Jurisdiction and merging The Methodist Church and the Evangelical United Brethren Church.  Both accomplishments were applauded as significant steps toward fulfilling Jesus’ prayer in John 17 “ that they may all be one.”

However, neither merger resulted in more disciples of Jesus Christ.  Indeed the percentage of African American members has decreased since the merger of 1968 and we have lost the numerical equivalent of the EUB Church.  In many towns where “German Methodism” flourished, there would be an EUB church and a Methodist Church on the same city street or rural community.  In the wake of the merger hundreds, if not thousands, of  those former EUB churches have closed or atrophied to very small memberships.   Merger was not a “bad thing,” but if in delineating the mission of the church “the main thing is to keep the main thing the main thing,”  we were inordinately infatuated with what Amos the prophet and Peter Berger the social analyst  called “the noise of solemn assemblies.”

Gradually, we developed an apropos wording for the Book of Discipline: “The mission of the local church is to make disciples of Jesus Christ and to transform the world.”   Aha! So the main thing is to make disciples who, in turn, become the salt  of the earth, the light of the world, and the leaven in the loaf of secular culture!   But here’s the “rub.”  We have not made disciples to offset those who have left our churches “for love of this present culture,” or for other faith communions, or by incapacitation and death.  Our professions of faith are an embarrassing statistic.   Confirmation is almost totally an educational experience of short duration and infrequent life-change.  Adult conversions come mostly through extra-parish experiences like “Walk to Emmaus” or non-UMC settings like Bible Study Fellowship or an evangelistic crusade(also a fading paradigm).  Some student conversions are through Wesley Foundation chapters, but the preponderance come through para-Christian groups like Campus Crusade for Christ, Young Life, Intervarsity Fellowship, Fellowship of Christian Athletes, etc.

Methodism was born on a university campus—Oxford. Why can we not connect with the college ethos today?  Most of our converts in the 19th century were among “the last, the least, and the lost.” Can we do it again, and if not, why? Have we become a people of affluence who are socio-economically possessed rather than Jesus centered? It’s time for reality check.

As I continue my column in the newly revised www.unitedmethodistreporter.com, I will be looking at how we can respond creatively to redeem and sacrifice some our old paradigms for God’s new work today.  I want to consider the “chemistry of conversion” we consider a new vision for where God is leading us.

Len Sweet calls us to see the church’s mission and the pulpit’s message as “following Jesus” rather than joining the church.  With his usual wise insight, he writes, “To follow Jesus does not mean to have all the answers…that you have it all together personally.. that suddenly all the shades go up and the shadows of life disappear. It just means that you keep on moving after the One you’ve said “YES” to.”

May we all keep moving to follow the great YES wherever that leads us.

Donald W. Haynes, UMR Columnist

Donald Haynes

Dr. Donald Haynes has been an ordained elder in the United Methodist Church for more than 50 years and is a member of the Western North Carolina Annual Conference. A recipient of the Harry Denman Evangelism Award, Dr. Haynes is the author of On the Threshold of Grace—Methodist Fundamentals; serves as an adjunct faculty member at Hood Theological Seminary; and is the Assistant to the Pastor in Evangelism at the First United Methodist Church of Asheboro, North Carolina. Dr. Haynes has written for The United Methodist Reporter since 2005.

Donald W. Haynes, UMR Columnist

Donald Haynes

Dr. Donald Haynes has been an ordained elder in the United Methodist Church for more than 50 years and is a member of the Western North Carolina Annual Conference. A recipient of the Harry Denman Evangelism Award, Dr. Haynes is the author of On the Threshold of Grace—Methodist Fundamentals; serves as an adjunct faculty member at Hood Theological Seminary; and is the Assistant to the Pastor in Evangelism at the First United Methodist Church of Asheboro, North Carolina. Dr. Haynes has written for The United Methodist Reporter since 2005.

Leave a Reply

The United Methodist Reporter wants to encourage lively conversation about The United Methodist Church and our articles in the belief that Christian conversation (what Wesley would call conferencing) is a means of grace. While we support passionate debate, we cannot allow language that demeans or demonizes others, and we reserve the right to delete any comment we believe to be harmful or inappropriate. We encourage all to remember that we are all broken and in need of Christ's grace, and that we all see through the glass darkly until that time we when reach full perfection in love. May your speech here be tempered with love, and reflection of the fruits of love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. After all, "There is no law against things like this." (Galatians 5:22-23)
3 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
cdar42js79country parson Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of

As a lay person, I believe the church I have attended for sixty-five years is portrayed as an "enemy" in this article. I disagree with much of Dr. Haynes statements, beginning with the first line about the South, which only serves to perpetuate the idea. along with what the North believes about the South. I do not believe birth control nor feminism or affluence have made Methodism irrelevant. We are relevant, and social justice is required of us. That is common sense, which Dr. Haynes seems to think we do not have. The devout Christian "affluent" persons sometimes do more… Read more »


I agree the UMC needs a reality check and that check is with the reality of God. Too often the UMC is defending either traditions that do not apply or its validation of the current culture. We have to live in the world that is but the problem is not affluence. We do not reach the last the least and the lost because we have lost God as he has become our last concern and is the least influence on our lives.

country parson
country parson

Thank you for this article. I do think we need a reality check. We claim the name Christian without any real effort to understand the Apostle Paul. We claim the name Methodist without any real understanding of our Methodist heritage. There was a "Golden Age" in Methodism… but I agree it was not in the '50's. Read the Autobiography of Peter Cartwright or check my blog at http://www.OurChristianHeritageFoundation.org Why are we not connecting with College Students??? Why are we not connecting with society in general? It is because Methodists have bought into a post-Kantian epistemology. Sad… even Kant believed in… Read more »

%d bloggers like this: